Knowledge transfer in or through clusters: outline of a situated approach
Clusters usually assume a dynamic of innovation at the cross-road between prox-imity and distance. On the one hand, proximity triggers trust and a sense of com-mon understanding between members that allow for the transfer of knowledge, especially its tacit components. But, at the same time, the innovativeness of the cluster also depends on distance: participants from different organizations with different skills, objectives and interests interact in a joint network. It creates a complex context for knowledge sharing, full of creative tensions and power issues. While insights from economic clusters (Porter 1998) or National (Lundvall 1992; Nelson 1993) and Regional Innovation Systems (Cooke et al. 1998; Asheim 2003) allow grasping the rationale behind the promotion of the innovation clus-ters, an important gap subsists in the understanding of the learning processes that are triggered, especially their political dimension. To make sure that such relation-ships keep their promises, it is important to understand what kinds of learning mechanisms are at stake and how partners ensure that the newly created knowledge is of interest for their parent organizations or themselves. Nevertheless, power issues and their impact on knowledge transfers have not been studied yet in the context of innovation clusters. One potential reason is the scarce use of frameworks that adequately manipulate such research objects. The goal of this chapter is therefore to outline a research approach for studying inter-organizational knowledge transfers in clusters as a situated, political process.